Dooba.net

Billshrink.com is an interesting site that lets you compare cell phones and services. They have a graphics that compares some pertinent features of the 3 big smartphones.

A few interesting points about this. The storage capacity is the base amount (or with the Pre the only amount). The G1 looks bad, but then again, it has a micro SD slot so you can put whatever you want in there.

Battery life for the G1 looks bad as well, but this is very different from other data (see last post) where standby was over 300hrs. However, as a G1 owner, I can say that standby time is not stellar, and I don’t think its really 300hrs.

Voice commands are interesting. The new Android 1.5 software has Google voice search. Which is interesting I guess, but most of the time I’m using my cell, its not ideal conditions for voice commands.

The app store should have listed an approximate number of apps available. Obvious the Apple App Store is the huge winner. Android Market isn’t bad, several thousand apps now. The Palm Catalog is new and has less than 20 apps, but we should give it a few months before passing judgement.

Multitasking is slightly misleading on the iPhone 3GS. The new 3.0 software has “notifications” so things like IM can “run” in the background. Or at least you could stay logged in and be notified when a new message comes in. Of course this isn’t real multitasking. And there is no way (that I have seen) to let 3rd party apps hook various system features. Android is great at this.

Finally, the thing that hurts the iPhone most in this chart is the service plan. ATT is more expensive than plans from T-Mobile or Sprint. I shopped plans myself, and I do a lot of txting and data, but don’t need a lot of minutes. Sprint ended up being cheapest – about $55 a month plus their free night minutes start at 7pm! T-mobile (my current carrier) was next cheapest at about $70. The win with them is the “My Favs”. I get unlimited calling any time to any three numbers. I use the Phonalyzr app to keep track of who most of my minutes go to, and set them as my favs. I have never gone over my minutes. ATT is fairly expensive by comparison. $20 extra just for unlimited messaging! My $25 unlimited data plan from T-Mobile includes unlimited SMS and MMS.

Bottom line from this graphic is the iPhone still has the edge in a apps and storage. But carrier selection hurts and still no true multitasking is a bummer. However, if the notifications service works well, that might be good enough for most people.

I’d been a Verizon customer for quite a few years and loved the service, coverage was great, 3G was fast, and for the most part customer service was good. Even the plans were ok.

But more and more it seems like VZ is falling behind in the phone department. Cruising their website shows a mediocre selection and some downright odd handsets.

Apple initially talked to VZ about the iPhone, and for whatever reason, they didn’t take it. Sure, it was probably a risk then, and maybe they would have had to give up a little control to do it.. but you know they are kicking themselves now.

Then came Android, and all the talk about how VZ had a falling out with the Open Handset Alliance. It seems they have rectified this, but still, there have been no handsets announced, and just rumors and statements saying they are coming.

And then VZ goes buck nutty about the Balckberry Storm. Initially it looked pretty good. BB has a great reputation for email devices, and a full touchscreen BB seemed pretty cool. I had one for about 6 months, and I wasn’t impressed, but thats another post.

And now Sprint has the Pre. I’ve played around with it a few times. Its a great phone, and a definite competitor. If they get their app store off the ground, this could be good times.

So, VZ, with the best network in the country, is left with nothing, while all the other big networks have a signature phone. They need to put down the beer and get with it. VZ is a joint venture with Vodafone… and Voda got the very cool HTC Magic. Why not VZ?

I switched to T-Mo to get an G1, and love Android. But I would switch back to VZ in a heartbeat if any one of the Android, iPhone, Pre options were available.